Evaero

Aerospace machining, CNC machining, titanium castings

  • Capabilities
  • About Us
  • Visiting Evaero
  • Work For Evaero
  • Contact Us

Truisms, The Tenth Amendment and the Constitution

January 10, 2019 Christian Frueh Topics: Politics

truisms tenth amendment

The amendment states but a truism that all is retained which has not been surrendered. ~ reference to the tenth amendment in United States v Darby (1941)

For the first part of this year, I’ll be writing articles addressing emails I received from readers in 2018.

With much focus on our southern border of late, I’ll start by answering a question I received about so-called “sanctuary cities.” Before I respond, however, I want to spend today talking about the Bill of Rights and its final, Tenth Amendment as it is relevant to my argument.

It’s worthwhile to note that, despite what many think, America’s Bill of Rights was not a product of the 1787 Constitutional Convention that ultimately brought us our Constitution. In fact, at the time, many believed a bill of rights to be unnecessary (and potentially dangerous). For that reason, it’s fair to speculate a bill of rights would have served as an impediment to the creation and subsequent ratification of the Constitution. As noted by the (nonpartisan) National Constitution Center:

The consistent line of the Constitution’s defenders was that no bill of rights was necessary because the limited and enumerated powers of the national government simply did not include the power to violate those rights. (source)

In other words, although a bill of rights might be necessary for a national government with unlimited powers, it didn’t make much sense for a national government granted limited powers by a Constitution.

The problem was that, as also noted by the National Constitution Center, “not everyone was convinced by these arguments” and, as such:

A number of states ratified the Constitution only on the express understanding that the document would quickly be amended to include a bill of rights. (source)

And so it was that four years later, in 1791, ten of the 12 amendments proposed by America’s first Congress were ratified as America’s Bill of Rights. However, to placate those concerned with government overreach and emphasize that the inclusion of a bill of rights wouldn’t change the fundamental character of the government, the framers ended with the tenth Amendment:

The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.

Reflecting on the words above, the Tenth Amendment can be viewed as a concise statement of Federalism; that is, there will be a central government of limited and enumerated powers and states with general powers within their borders. Or, as noted in the quote that heads this blog and also this piece by Charles Cooper at the (conservative) Heritage Foundation, the Tenth Amendment is but a truism since it merely restates what’s in the Constitution; namely, powers not delegated to the federal government belong to the states or the people.

What does all of this have to do with sanctuary cities? More on that next week but to hold you over I’m going to leave you a song by Lean Year titled “Tenth Amendment.”

The song is featured in an album (The Most Perfect Album) that was put together as part of Radiolab’s excellent podcast about the Supreme Court, More Perfect. The album features artists offering their interpretations of the 27 amendments through their original songs. I didn’t know about the band Lean Year until I heard the podcast and really dug the song. I think the following lines do a succinct job of summarizing part of the essential tension that holds our wonderful experiment together:

Will your we put an end to me?
Will your me put an end to we?

Until next week.

Cheers…xian

Video not displaying properly? Click here.

Print Friendly, PDF & EmailPrintFriendly
Share this article:
Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on google
Google
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
Linkedin
Share on email
Email
Share on buffer
Buffer

About Christian Frueh

With a Ph.D in Materials Science and Engineering and a minor in Anthropology, Christian is a thoughtful leader who looks at things from a scientific perspective: Solve problems, don’t make assumptions.

Read more about Christian

Latest from the blog

The Role of Weight in Casting to Hog-out Conversions

September 17, 2015

ISO quality management system

Failing More Often: Gaining from Randomness and Volatility

February 5, 2015

Improving Precision CNC Aerospace Machining

January 22, 2015

About Evaero

Evaero is a modern manufacturing firm delivering custom machined components to the aerospace and defense industry.

Learn more

Print Friendly, PDF & EmailPrintFriendly

Connect With Evaero

  • Email
  • RSS

Phone:
775-5EV-AERO
(775.538.2376)

Address: 

3807 E. Kleindale Rd.
Tucson, AZ 85716

Print Friendly, PDF & EmailPrintFriendly
© 2023 Manufacturing Peace of Mind, LLC. All rights reserved.
 Twitter
 Facebook