Evaero

Aerospace machining, CNC machining, titanium castings

  • Capabilities
  • About Us
  • Visiting Evaero
  • Work For Evaero
  • Contact Us

What is a Sanctuary City?

January 17, 2019 Christian Frueh Topics: Politics

what is a sanctuary city

Alien enemies are under the law of nations, and liable to be punished for offences against it. Alien friends, except in the single case of public ministers, are under the municipal law, and must be tried and punished according to that law only. ~ James Madison (source)

I have quite a few readers of this blog who live outside the U.S. and last year I was asked for my thoughts about so-called “sanctuary cities.” With immigration having become a divisive issue not just in America but throughout the world, I have several thoughts. But first, let’s clarify what we mean by sanctuary city.

Ask someone here in the U.S. of what they think of sanctuary cities and, depending on who you talk to, one will likely be left with one of two impressions:

  • They are cities harboring illegal aliens*.
  • They are cities providing sanctuary to the least, the last, and the lost.

It turns out, however, that neither of these impressions is technically correct.

Whether a city is deemed to be a sanctuary city or not pertains solely to how local law enforcement handles a request from federal law enforcement to detain an illegal alien past the point of when they should legally be released**.

A sanctuary city will release an illegal alien that has not committed a serious crime after he has been cleared of charges. In contrast, a non-sanctuary city will, if requested by way of a federal detainer, hold that person until he is picked up by federal law enforcement.

Now, some may view the holding of an illegal alien by local law enforcement past the point of when they should be released as a simple courtesy to federal law enforcement. After all, with the large number of illegal aliens living in our country (10 to 12 million is the number I’ve seen reported) that Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) needs help and cooperation is totally understandable. However, as someone who is keenly aware of the reminder offered by the Tenth Amendment to our Constitution (see last week’s article), I personally view these requests as an intrusion on local government.

Does that put me in the camp of pro-illegal alien groups who are pushing for open borders and wanting to abolish ICE?

Nope.

I’m simply someone who believes as Adjunct Scholar at the Cato Institute David Post does that:

Jurisdictions that refuse to honor such requests are not providing “sanctuary” for people who break the law; they are providing “constitutional protections” for those individuals. (Washington Post)

Further, in my view, while I believe local law enforcement should assist ICE and other federal agencies that have the authority and jurisdiction to enforce our nation’s immigration laws (local agencies do not), they should not be asked/expected to act outside the confines of the law to do so.

On that note, a good time to end this blog and get ready to start my day. Before I do so, how about some music for our Manufacturing Peace of Mind™ Spotify playlist? Here then, off their new release Cocoa Sugar, is the Scottish band Young Fathers with their song “In My View.” The album is quite good and, as noted by The Guardian, “full of impressionistic, ambiguous lyrics, mixing biblical allusions, non sequiturs, and ancient proverbs.”

Cheers…xian

*An individual in America who is not a citizen is termed under federal law to be an “alien.” Therefore, an alien who is here without legal permission is by definition an “illegal alien.”

**With a few exceptions, aliens are in fact granted rights under our constitution; for example, the Fifth Amendment grants the right of due process and the Fourth Amendment protects from unreasonable search and seizure.

Video not displaying properly? Click here.

Print Friendly, PDF & EmailPrintFriendly
Share this article:
Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on google
Google
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
Linkedin
Share on email
Email
Share on buffer
Buffer

About Christian Frueh

With a Ph.D in Materials Science and Engineering and a minor in Anthropology, Christian is a thoughtful leader who looks at things from a scientific perspective: Solve problems, don’t make assumptions.

Read more about Christian

Latest from the blog

The Role of Weight in Casting to Hog-out Conversions

September 17, 2015

ISO quality management system

Failing More Often: Gaining from Randomness and Volatility

February 5, 2015

Improving Precision CNC Aerospace Machining

January 22, 2015

About Evaero

Evaero is a modern manufacturing firm delivering custom machined components to the aerospace and defense industry.

Learn more

Print Friendly, PDF & EmailPrintFriendly

Connect With Evaero

  • Email
  • RSS

Phone:
775-5EV-AERO
(775.538.2376)

Address: 

3807 E. Kleindale Rd.
Tucson, AZ 85716

Print Friendly, PDF & EmailPrintFriendly
© 2023 Manufacturing Peace of Mind, LLC. All rights reserved.
 Twitter
 Facebook